Three Ways To Do Dialogue Attributes Wrong
One of the first novels I wrote,
when I was, ye gods, twelve or thirteen, I don't remember (or I have
thankfully blanked the memory from my brain) was Star Trek
fanfic. On the first draft, the dialogue looked something like this: "Maybe the attacker was a Klingon," said Kirk. "That is not logical, Captain," said Spock. "But he looked like a Klingon," said Kirk. "But then he turned into a furry white snow monster," said Spock.
"That's what puzzles me," said Kirk. And so on. image: Marc Wathieu Well, neophyte though I was, even I could tell that was
terrible dialogue. (And it tended to go on for three pages). But why, WHY did it suck rocks? That's what I needed to pin down. Probably
because so much was wrong, I settled on the most obvious (to me)
problem, the boring repetition of "said."